Is It True Our Forgiven Student Loan Debt is Only Taxable Up to the Point We Become Insolvent?

By on December 20, 2018

Question:

Dear Steve,

My husband and I did one of those awful spousal consolidations years ago. He originally borrowed about 100K and I borrowed 30K.

We have since added another 100K in Parent Plus loans. which we have consolidated and are currently on an ICRP. The balance is over 400K at this point.

We just recently re-consolidated when our son finished school. I left one of his loans out so I can re-consolidate in about 5 years to start the clock over.

We are doing the “die before our 25 years is up“, plan. My husband is 62 and I am 58. So our clock just started over.

I just read about this insolvency thing. Are you saying that if our debts are higher than our assets in 25 yrs we would not owe that tax bill?

Our house will be paid off, probably worth 250K, a little in retirement BUT that loan will be massive by then – probably a million bucks I would imagine. Again my plan was to leave this one little loan out and reconsolidate again in 5-7 years but maybe we don’t have to do that? What a mess! Thanks for any help.

Tammy

Answer:

Dear Tammy,

As you can imagine, the technical answer is a bit nuanced. It’s easier most of the time just to mention the insolvency exception because get ready for it, here is the full answer:

You may be taxed, as ordinary income, on the amount of the forgiven debt up to the point you become insolvent. For example, if your assets are $250,000 and you receive $1 million in forgiveness, then you could be taxed on $250,000 of the forgiveness.

The IRS says, “Normally, a taxpayer is not required to include forgiven debts in income to the extent that the taxpayer is insolvent.” –

The IRS also says, “The tax impact of debt forgiveness or cancellation depends on your individual facts and circumstances. Generally, if you borrow money from a commercial lender and the lender later cancels or forgives the debt, you may have to include the cancelled amount in income for tax purposes. The lender is usually required to report the amount of the canceled debt to you and the IRS on a Form 1099-C, Cancellation of Debt.” –

READ  How to Claim the Insolvency Exemption for Canceled Debt Reported on Form 1099-C

IRS Publication 4681 has a worksheet to help with this calculation.

The publication also provides an example.

Amount of insolvency less than canceled debt. The facts are the same as in Example 1 except that Greg’s total liabilities immediately before the cancellation were $10,000 and the FMV of his total assets immediately before the cancellation was $7,000. In this case, Greg is insolvent to the extent of $3,000 ($10,000 total liabilities minus $7,000 FMV of his total assets) immediately before the cancellation. Because the amount of the canceled debt was more than the amount by which Greg was insolvent immediately before the cancellation, Greg can exclude only $3,000 of the $5,000 canceled debt from income under the insolvency exclusion.

Greg checks the box on line 1b of Form 982 and includes $3,000 on line 2. Also, Greg completes Part II to reduce his tax attributes as explained under Reduction of Tax Attributes, later. Additionally, Greg must include $2,000 of canceled debt on line 21 of his Form 1040 (unless another exclusion applies).” – Source

The problem with this situation in general is we are talking about tax code or tax law, and I am neither a tax expert nor a lawyer. In addition, the law may change greatly decades from now. No crystal ball to check on that.

It is a total mess and there are some additional tricks to push this out further. You might want to talk to a knowledge expert in person or have a chat with my good friend and debt expert who is a pro in these areas. You can easily push this out past your expected death date and then it’s problem solved.

Yes, it is a total mess.

morehelp1
Choice1 Choice3 Big Hug!
Euro-Video - , ,
If you have a credit or debt question you'd like to ask just use the online form .

Last step, fill out the information below or call us for Priority Assistance.

What problems are you having with your report?

Your first name is required. Your first name is required to be at least 2 characters. Your first name cannot be longer than 50 characters.
Your last name is required. Your last name is required to be at least 2 characters. Your last name cannot be longer than 50 characters.
Your email is required.
Your phone is required. Your 10 digit phone number is required.
Your state is required.
Your age is required. Your age must be greater than 18. Your age must be less than 100.

By clicking on the "Contact Me" button above, you consent, acknowledge, and agree to the following: Our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and to receive electronic communications. We take your privacy seriously. That you are providing express "written" consent for Debt.com or appropriate service provider(s) to call you (including through automated means; e.g. autodialing, text and pre-recorded messaging) via telephone, mobile device (including SMS and MMS - charges may apply), even if your telephone number is currently listed on any internal, corporate, state or federal Do-Not-Call list. Consent is not required as a condition to utilize Debt.com services and you are under no obligation to purchase anything.

By clicking on the “Contact me” button above, you consent, acknowledge, and agree to the following: (1)That you are providing express “written” consent for Lexington Law Firm, Debt.com or appropriate service provider(s) to call you (including through automated means; e.g. autodialing, text and pre-recorded messaging) via telephone, mobile device (including SMS and MMS – charges may apply), or dialed manually, at my residential or cellular number, even if your telephone number is currently listed on any internal, corporate, state or federal Do-Not-Call list; and (2)Lexington Law’s and and Debt.com’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Consent is not required as a condition to utilize Lexington Law or Debt.com services and you are under no obligation to purchase anything.

About Steve Rhode

Steve Rhode is the Euro-Video and has been helping good people with bad debt problems since 1994. You can learn more about Steve, here.

2 Comments

  1. Tammy

    December 20, 2018 at 1:38 pm

    Asked question.

Share a Comment / Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: